Heretic to Housewife

Posted on January 13, 2015 by Rahne Alexander

Photo via Stoop Storytelling.

“Please tell my story,” was the refrain my mother, Judith, repeated to me frequently in her last several years. Her health was in long, slow decline; her body suffering the constant subterfuge of multiple sclerosis, polio, and more. Her mother had been brought down by Alzheimer’s, her father leukemia. I knew a lot about disease for a six-year-old.

I was on a post-punk trajectory, increasingly caught up in the fury brought on by a clear consciousness of myself as a trans girl in a time and place where my only hope for survival was the dog-eared “transsexuality” page of a medical encyclopedia.  The barrage of sexist requirements levied by the church quickly turned religious skepticism into stone-cold rejection, the unfortunate side effect of which was adding another, greater obstacle between me and my mother.

My mother was a devout woman. She was also a badass. She was a dancer. When polio stopped her from that, she took up painting and drawing, teaching herself to make pointillist portraits of flowers, butterflies, and birds until the sclera destroyed her motor control. As the loss of her art progressed, she also lost her substantial capacity for domesticity. She reupholstered furniture. She made yogurt. She made four children.

As a young woman, she’d gone on a mission for her church, proselytizing in a degenerate desert gambling town at a time when a number of her peers would have been denouncing Betty Friedan as a radical.  She was an incredible organizer; her capacity cathexed in one scene in my childhood memory—returning from a meeting of some committee of which she was the newly-appointed chair, she was disgusted to have had to explain to other adults the meaning of the word “agenda.”

I am thoroughly my mother’s daughter. She taught me everything about being a woman in this world, in spite of the fact that she went through the motions of raising me as a boy. She was adamant in delineating the importance of being a lady over being a mere woman; presciently, she didn’t exactly parallel those lessons in masculine terms.

Early in my first year of college I dove headlong into feminist cultural criticism; I was thirsty.  Of particular interest was the memoir called Housewife to Heretic, about a devout member of my parents’ church who was ultimately excommunicated because she campaigned in support of the Equal Rights Amendment. My own heresy was already inevitable, but still I did my best to smuggle in what I learned to my mother, to my sisters, before all was revealed and I was shut out.

I am certain now that all along, my parents—and my mother in particular—were aware that I would not be the son that they desired. The language we have now didn’t exist then, and the concepts were undoubtedly frightening. Despite her fears, when I revealed my plans to transition, my mother met my challenge with a surprising degree of acceptance.  She held on to her faith; it was the thing that kept her going, decades after she could have given up the ghost.

The years progressed and as I gained a greater capacity to communicate, her capacity to hold on to memories diminished and the heartbreak that remains with me is that I will never be able to have a clear sense of what it was like for my mother to incrementally lose her capacities and to watch her children – me in particular – follow paths that were undoubtedly both familiar and strange.

I tried, on occasion, to get her to speak about her hard times: Her experience as an independent woman who had had a rocky relationship with her own mother. Her experience as a woman who suffered the constant betrayal of her own body. Her experience as a woman who was at the mercy of a medical system that experimented on her. These topics were our most common ground, and I felt such guilt in asking her to exhume those pains when she had already suffered so much that I just stopped.

To my mind, this is one of the ultimate feminist challenges: to negotiate that fraught mother-daughter divide, to somehow weave together the inevitable failures with the unexpected successes and churn out some sort of fantastic fabric, an incredible yarn which is only held together by truth, whatever that is.

My mother’s father was on his deathbed when he told her that my infant hands were “writer’s hands.” I’ve always thought it was a ridiculous thing to say, and she never let go of the notion. I don’t know why I still feel so defensive about this scene—I am a writer, whether I like it or not, and so she always thought of me as a writer, and asked, demanded, repeatedly that I tell her story. I still do not feel qualified to speak for her, but I am here, and she asked me to do so, and this is a beginning.

13 Comments

  • Courtney Eckler February 4, 2015 at 3:22 am

    This is Beautiful! Brings up so much of the struggles in my relationship with my mother (who I am so thankful just celebrated her 89th birthday.) I am her transgender daughter and she has been teaching me how to be a lady my entire life – I feel she always somehow knew I was destined to be her daughter. We have fought like all mothers and daughters but always came out of it a little closer. She gave me my love for language and writing. She is my role model for self reliance and courage after my parents divorced and she had to pull us out of potential poverty by going back to Goucher for an advanced degree in teaching. Support for my transition didn’t come easy at first but soon she championed my journey. Like Rahne, I too am entirely my mother’s daughter. This piece brought tears to my eyes as it reminded me of the gift my mother has given me in nurturing the woman I have become. Thank you Rahne!

    Reply
  • Courtney Eckler February 4, 2015 at 3:17 am

    This is Beautiful! Brings up so much of the struggles in my relationship with my mother (who I am so thankful just celebrated her 89th birthday.) I am her transgender daughter and she has been teaching me how to be a lady my entire life – I feel she always somehow knew I was destined to be her daughter. We have fought like all mothers and daughters but always came out of it a little closer. She gave me my love for language and writing. She is my role model for self reliance and courage after my parents divorced and she had to pull us out of potential poverty by going back to Goucher for an advanced degree in teaching. Support for my transition didn’t come easy at first but soon she championed my journey. Like Rahne, I too am entirely my mother’s daughter. This piece brought tears to my eyes as it reminded me of the gift my mother has given me in nurturing the woman I have become. Thank you Rahne!

    Reply
  • Elizabeth Downing January 22, 2015 at 8:39 am

    Weeping now. Thank you Rahne.

    Reply
  • Summer January 21, 2015 at 7:59 pm

    “…this is one of the ultimate feminist challenges: to negotiate that fraught mother-daughter divide, to somehow weave together the inevitable failures with the unexpected successes and churn out some sort of fantastic fabric, an incredible yarn which is only held together by truth, whatever that is.”
    Rahne, you nailed it here, for me, at least.

    My mother & I are very close, in both chronological years and relationship, and we are both biological-born and identified females, but the feminism that defined many of her choices and sensibilities (and was a huge part of my upbringing), has evolved into new conversations about feminism that constantly bring us into the divide you speak of. I think that the ever-evolving understanding of what it means to be a woman, and how to be your best woman-self, in this period in history, is only bettered, and furthered, by opening up dialogues (as your article does). It ain’t easy being a lady. Thanks for the thoughtful essay, Rahne!

    Reply
  • norma cohen January 21, 2015 at 5:22 pm

    Who knew that baby-hands were so prophetic. Your mom would be proud.

    Reply
  • Sandy Asirvatham January 21, 2015 at 4:20 am

    Beautiful, Rahne. Keep going.

    Reply
  • Tim Ward Baltimore Poet-Writer January 20, 2015 at 3:38 pm

    Thanks Rahne, you are a writer as this shows and I would be proud to do as well.

    Reply
  • Connell O'Donovan January 20, 2015 at 2:08 pm

    This brought tears to my eyes, sweet Rahne! I’m so honored to know you from our Santa Cruz daze…much love! Connell

    Reply
  • tallie ben daniel January 20, 2015 at 1:40 pm

    I have been waiting since the days of the Foucauldian Ho to read more of your writing. So excited about this, and this is so beautiful!

    Reply
  • Donna Thornton-Long January 20, 2015 at 1:29 pm

    This is beautiful, Rahne…

    Reply
  • Mi13 January 20, 2015 at 12:58 pm

    Beautiful.

    Reply
  • Mike White January 20, 2015 at 12:49 pm

    So proud to know you, Rahne!

    Reply
    • Becka January 22, 2015 at 6:41 pm

      Reading this brought up a lot and I wanted to share in this and express the value this topic has had on my life.
      My oldest brother transgendered into my sister after our mother passed away. It was a difficult time and probably the perfect time for her to try a new dynamic. She took on a variation of our mothers name which showed an amount of endearment I didn’t know she was capable of. Her empathy for feminism & racism started to grow. Her happiness did as well. I’ll admit her growling at pronoun misusage made me twing. I spent 26 years referring to zim in masculine pronoun. It was going to take a few months at least to learn the language.
      I moved away and have not visited for a while. My chest gets heavy and my eyes wet when I hear how at family reunions she is mistaken as me. We are not close and I want deeply to understand her journey and her experiences through her development but she is not open to connecting emotionally. I now openly embrace transgender individuals and connect on their journey, wanting to express validation.
      Her choice has made me look harder at my choices and I will love her for whatever form bending she wants to experience, in whatever area of life she chooses. She’s made me more open and accepting because that’s what I chose to see. Thank you for sharing. There are not enough outlets for this kind of complex processing. I’m glad you’ve chosen to take the great lessons from your mother and project them back into the world.

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *